8 hours ago
3
| ← Previous revision | Revision as of 14:44, 13 July 2025 | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
'''Drive-by comment''': [[WP:SONGS]] suggests that a section detailing the track listings for singles should not be included in articles as a standard practice (see [[WP:SINGLETRACKLIST]]). I don't see any mention of the remixes in the article's body, let alone "extensive commentary", so the 'Track listing and formats' section should probably be removed. [[User:Leafy46|Leafy46]] ([[User talk:Leafy46|talk]]) 00:14, 13 July 2025 (UTC) |
'''Drive-by comment''': [[WP:SONGS]] suggests that a section detailing the track listings for singles should not be included in articles as a standard practice (see [[WP:SINGLETRACKLIST]]). I don't see any mention of the remixes in the article's body, let alone "extensive commentary", so the 'Track listing and formats' section should probably be removed. [[User:Leafy46|Leafy46]] ([[User talk:Leafy46|talk]]) 00:14, 13 July 2025 (UTC) |
||
:Thank you for the feedback <nowiki>{{ping|user:Leafy46}}</nowiki>!. While WP:SONGS does caution against including single track listings by default, it also allows for exceptions where the content is contextually relevant and well-sourced. In this case, ''"La Isla Bonita"'' was released in multiple formats (7", 12", CD, digital single), each with varying B-sides and remixes. |
:Thank you for the feedback {{ping|user:Leafy46}}!. While WP:SONGS does caution against including single track listings by default, it also allows for exceptions where the content is contextually relevant and well-sourced. In this case, ''"La Isla Bonita"'' was released in multiple formats (7", 12", CD, digital single), each with varying B-sides and remixes. |
||
:Other Featured Articles of songs such as ''"[[Bad Romance]]'' and ''"[[Never Forget You (Mariah Carey song)]]"'' have retained similar sections. I’m happy to trim the section for brevity or integrate remix mentions into the prose if that’s preferred by consensus, but given the historical breadth and documentation of this single’s various formats, I believe the section is appropriate here. [[User:Chrishm21|Christian]] ([[User talk:Chrishm21|talk]]) 14:44, 13 July 2025 (UTC) |
:Other Featured Articles of songs such as ''"[[Bad Romance]]'' and ''"[[Never Forget You (Mariah Carey song)]]"'' have retained similar sections. I’m happy to trim the section for brevity or integrate remix mentions into the prose if that’s preferred by consensus, but given the historical breadth and documentation of this single’s various formats, I believe the section is appropriate here. [[User:Chrishm21|Christian]] ([[User talk:Chrishm21|talk]]) 14:44, 13 July 2025 (UTC) |
||
