Talk:Abbas ibn Ali

Hey guys, as a Shia muslim, who visited Karbala each year, i know that the 7th day of muharram is the mourning day for abbas (3). Though i don’t have official sources for it. Could someone help out? [[User:Mortajaboi|Mortajaboi]] ([[User talk:Mortajaboi|talk]]) 22:43, 20 July 2024 (UTC)

Hey guys, as a Shia muslim, who visited Karbala each year, i know that the 7th day of muharram is the mourning day for abbas (3). Though i don’t have official sources for it. Could someone help out? [[User:Mortajaboi|Mortajaboi]] ([[User talk:Mortajaboi|talk]]) 22:43, 20 July 2024 (UTC)

== Clarification: Compliance with user‑generated image guidelines ==

== Clarification: Compliance with user-generated image guidelines ==

Thank you for referencing the new guidelines regarding user-generated graphics. I would like to clarify why this depiction complies and respectfully request reconsideration for re-inclusion:

# '''User-created and freely licensed''': This is an original vector illustration created by hand (not AI-generated), released under a free license (e.g., CC BY-SA), consistent with [[Wikipedia:Image use policy]] and [[Wikipedia:Uploading images]].

# '''Not AI-generated''': The policy on AI-generated visuals ([[Wikipedia:Artificial intelligence visual artistry#Usage in Wikipedia|AI image use]]) restricts only wholly AI-generated content; this image is human-designed.

# '''Relevant and encyclopedic''': The image adds cultural and theological insight not present elsewhere in the article, in accordance with [[Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Images#Relevance|MOS:IMAGERELEVANCE]].

# '''Religious and cultural respect''': The faceless design adheres to Shia Islamic visual norms, accurately honoring the subject without misrepresentation.

Thank you for referencing the new guidelines regarding user‑generated graphics. I would like to clarify why this depiction complies with them and respectfully request reconsideration for re‑inclusion:

# '''User‑created and freely licensed''': This image is an original vector illustration created by the artist (not AI-generated) and is released under a free license (e.g., CC BY‑SA), as required by [[Wikipedia:Image use policy]] and [[Wikipedia:Uploading images]].

# '''Not AI‑generated''': Under the policy on AI images ([[Wikipedia:Image use policy § AI‑generated images]] and [[Wikipedia:Artificial intelligence visual art]]), only images created wholly by AI are restricted. This is entirely human-designed content.

# '''Relevant and encyclopedic''': It visually conveys cultural and theological aspects of Abbas ibn Ali not present in other images, in line with [[Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Images#Relevance|MOS:IMAGERELEVANCE]].

# '''Religious and cultural respect''': The faceless design aligns with Shia Islamic norms and enhances respect for the subject, rather than causing confusion or misinformation.

=== Proposed caption for restored image ===

=== Proposed caption for restored image ===

<nowiki>

<nowiki>[[File:Abbas ibn Ali.png|thumb|right|Faceless vector portrait of Abbas ibn Ali in accordance with Shia visual tradition (designed by Muntadher Saleh, CC BY‑SA).]]</nowiki>

[[[[File:Abbas ibn Ali.png|thumb|Abbas ibn Ali]]|thumb]]

I believe this image meets all current guidelines and respectfully request its reintegration. Happy to provide additional licensing details or discuss further. [[User:004bvan|004bvan]] ([[User talk:004bvan|talk]]) 13:52, 5 July 2025 (UTC)

Faceless vector portrait of Abbas ibn Ali in accordance with Shia visual tradition (designed by Muntadher Saleh, CC BY‑SA).]]</nowiki>

Given that this image fully complies with current image-use guidelines, I respectfully request its restoration. I am happy to provide additional licensing information or discuss further if needed.

10:15, 5 July 2025 (UTC)