Das Judenthum in der Musik

6 days ago 165

Reverted unsourced and misleading addition. The claim that Hitler used a term "coined by Wagner" is speculative and lacks citation. Terms like "Verjudung" predate both Wagner and Hitler and were in broader antisemitic use. Drawing a straight causal line from Wagner to Nazi rhetoric without context oversimplifies the history of language and ideology. As a parallel: the term Entartung ("degeneracy") was coined by Jewish critic Max Nordau to attack Wagner, yet later became in Nazi use against Jews

← Previous revision Revision as of 03:10, 14 July 2025
Line 67: Line 67:


Hitler was known to be an enthusiastic admirer of Wagner's music, and the music was frequently played during Nazi party rallies (along with the music of other German composers) as exemplifying German cultural supremacy.<ref>Dennis, 1996 pp. 142–174</ref> While Hitler owned several of Wagner's [[Music manuscript|music manuscripts]] as prized possessions, there is no evidence Hitler and other Nazi leadership members read ''Das Judenthum'' or were even aware of its existence.<ref>Evans, 2005</ref> As the essay was largely regarded as an embarrassment to the early Wagnerites, there was just one reprint of the essay in [[Weimar]] in 1914, before the Nazis came to power. During the Nazi era there were two further publications: in Berlin in 1934 and in Leipzig in 1939. Neither of these appear to have been large editions with significant readership.
Hitler was known to be an enthusiastic admirer of Wagner's music, and the music was frequently played during Nazi party rallies (along with the music of other German composers) as exemplifying German cultural supremacy.<ref>Dennis, 1996 pp. 142–174</ref> While Hitler owned several of Wagner's [[Music manuscript|music manuscripts]] as prized possessions, there is no evidence Hitler and other Nazi leadership members read ''Das Judenthum'' or were even aware of its existence.<ref>Evans, 2005</ref> As the essay was largely regarded as an embarrassment to the early Wagnerites, there was just one reprint of the essay in [[Weimar]] in 1914, before the Nazis came to power. During the Nazi era there were two further publications: in Berlin in 1934 and in Leipzig in 1939. Neither of these appear to have been large editions with significant readership.

However nazi musicologist Karl Blessinger drew upon Wagner's anti-semitic ideas and language in publications during the nazi era and Hitler came to use the Wagner-coined phrase of "Jewification" ("Verjudung") in Mein Kampf.


The essay has since served as an important document to understand the nature of Wagner's antisemitic worldview and whether this antisemitism is present in [[List of works for the stage by Richard Wagner|his stage works]]. Scholars such as [[Theodor Adorno]] have asserted that it is present,<ref>Adorno, 1952</ref> but this is strongly disputed by others.<ref>Katz, 1986</ref> The topic remains under [[Controversies surrounding Richard Wagner|considerable debate]] in both academia and amongst the opera-going public. With a few controversial exceptions, Wagner has not been publicly performed in what is today the modern state of Israel since 1938.
The essay has since served as an important document to understand the nature of Wagner's antisemitic worldview and whether this antisemitism is present in [[List of works for the stage by Richard Wagner|his stage works]]. Scholars such as [[Theodor Adorno]] have asserted that it is present,<ref>Adorno, 1952</ref> but this is strongly disputed by others.<ref>Katz, 1986</ref> The topic remains under [[Controversies surrounding Richard Wagner|considerable debate]] in both academia and amongst the opera-going public. With a few controversial exceptions, Wagner has not been publicly performed in what is today the modern state of Israel since 1938.
Open Full Post